Rhode Island criminal defense
Rhode Island Probation Violation Hearings
In Rhode Island, a probation violation is decided at a hearing before the District Court or Superior Court that placed you on probation, not at the trial of any new charge. Under R.I. Gen. Laws §§ 12-19-9 and 12-19-14, the hearing comes within 30 days of arrest unless waived, and the state must prove the violation by a fair preponderance of the evidence. DiLibero & Associates defends probation, suspended sentence and deferred sentence violations across Rhode Island from its Providence office.
How probation and suspended sentences work in Rhode Island
Under R.I. Gen. Laws § 12-19-8(a), the Superior Court or District Court may impose a sentence and suspend its execution in whole or in part. It may also place you on probation without a suspended sentence. A suspension places you on probation for the time the court fixes, on the conditions set under § 12-19-8.1.
The length is capped. Under § 12-19-8(b), felony probation is set as the law requires or under the judicial sentencing benchmarks. Misdemeanor probation, where no sentence is imposed or the sentence is entirely suspended, may run up to the maximum sentence for the offense. Where part of a sentence is served, the time served plus the probation period may not exceed the statutory maximum.
What is at stake at a violation hearing is the suspended time. If you received five years with one to serve and four suspended, the four years are what the court can order served. Days spent in confinement awaiting trial or sentencing are credited against any sentence (§ 12-19-2(a)).
How a probation violation is alleged: new charge or technical violation
Rhode Island law separates two kinds of violations. The first is a new criminal charge. The second is a technical violation, a breach of a condition that is not itself a crime. Examples are a missed appointment, a failed test, an unpaid obligation or an incomplete program. Which statute applies depends on how the sentence was structured.
Section 12-19-9 covers probation imposed under § 12-19-8. The police or the probation authority informs the attorney general of a violation, and the attorney general causes you to appear before the court. The department of corrections division of rehabilitative services promptly renders a report on your conduct. The division may recommend that the time already served is a sufficient response to a violation that is not a new alleged crime.
Section 12-19-14 covers probation by suspension of execution of sentence under § 12-19-13. When you are formally charged with a new crime, the police or the division causes you to appear. For a technical violation, the division decides whether one occurred and causes you to appear. Its written report must describe, where applicable, the clear and articulable public safety risk you pose. It may again recommend time served.
Being held without bail. Under § 12-19-9(a), the court may hold you without bail for up to 10 days, excluding Saturdays, Sundays and holidays. Under § 12-19-14(a), that hold is available when the new charge is a violent crime, a domestic violence crime or a driving under the influence crime. It is also available when the court finds that public safety or your likelihood of appearing warrants it.
One technical violation is written into another statute. Failure to complete a court-ordered batterer's intervention program in a domestic violence case is itself a basis for a violation under § 12-29-5(a). If your original case was a domestic violence case, read our Rhode Island domestic violence defense page alongside this one.
The 32(f) hearing: timing, standard of proof and your rights
Lawyers call this a 32(f) hearing, after Rule 32(f) of the Superior Court Rules of Criminal Procedure. Under the rule, the court may not revoke probation, revoke a suspended sentence or impose a deferred sentence without a hearing. You must be given the opportunity to be present and be apprised of the grounds. Before the hearing, the state must give you and the court a written statement of the grounds. You may be admitted to bail pending the hearing. No revocation may occur unless the state proves a breach by a fair preponderance of the evidence. The breach can be a violated condition or a failure to keep the peace or remain on good behavior.
The statutes match the rule. Under §§ 12-19-9(b) and 12-19-14(b), the court holds the hearing within 30 days of arrest unless you waive that limit. You have the opportunity to be present and to respond. The court decides by a fair preponderance of the evidence, in open court and in your presence.
A fair preponderance is a lower standard than proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The question is whether you violated the terms of probation, not whether you are guilty of the new charge. That is why a violation can be found before the new case is tried, and why the hearing deserves its own preparation. An allegation alone does not tell you the outcome. The division's report and recommendation are part of what the court weighs.
What the court can do if it finds a violation
If the court finds a violation, §§ 12-19-9(b) and 12-19-14(b) give it five options:
- Remove the suspension and order you committed on the sentence previously imposed, or on a lesser sentence
- Impose a sentence if none was previously imposed
- Stay all or a portion of the sentence imposed after removal of the suspension
- Continue the suspension of the sentence previously imposed
- Convert a sentence of probation without incarceration to a suspended sentence
The court sentences for a violation in accordance with the judicial sentencing benchmarks (§ 12-19-9(c)). Rule 35 of the Superior Court rules adds that the court may reduce a suspended sentence when it revokes probation. The lesser-sentence and stay options are where mitigation is argued: treatment, work, family responsibilities, the nature of the violation and the division's own time-served recommendation.
If the new charge collapses. R.I. Gen. Laws § 12-19-18(b) protects a person sentenced to imprisonment for a violation based on an alleged new crime after an evidentiary hearing. On motion, that sentence must be quashed and the imprisonment ended when the new charge ends in one of these ways:
- A not guilty verdict after trial, or a judgment of acquittal or dismissal under Rule 29
- A no true bill from the grand jury after it hears evidence
- A no information based on a lack of probable cause
- A dismissal under § 12-12-1.7 or Superior Court Rule 9.1
- The charge fails to proceed because the state indicates a lack of probable cause, or doubt about the accused's culpability
Under § 12-19-18(a), the same relief applies to a person imprisoned for violating a deferred sentence because of an alleged felony. That sentence is quashed on motion if the grand jury fails to indict or no information is filed. The section does not limit the court's power to revoke for conduct that is not criminal (§ 12-19-18(c)).
The violation hearing and the new criminal case are two tracks
A new arrest while on probation creates two proceedings. The violation hearing on the old case and the prosecution of the new charge move separately, often in different courts and on different dates. The violation hearing usually comes first because of the 30-day rule. Each has its own standard of proof and its own consequences.
Coordinated preparation matters. What is said at the violation hearing is on the record while the new case is still pending. Bring the papers for both cases and tell counsel about every upcoming date. Do not assume that one proceeding determines the other.
A dismissal of the new charge does not automatically undo a violation finding, but § 12-19-18 provides a remedy when the dismissal is on a listed ground. Our post on Rhode Island probation violations after a new criminal charge walks through the two tracks and the paperwork for each.
Deferred sentences and filings are handled like probation violations
Deferred sentences. A deferred sentence is available only in the Superior Court after a plea of guilty or nolo contendere. Under § 12-19-19(a), you and the court sign a written deferral agreement filed with the clerk. The court may impose sentence only within five years of the agreement, unless you are found to have violated its terms during that period. A violation is determined under the probation violation procedures in the court rules and §§ 12-19-2 and 12-19-14. The court may then impose a sanction or a sentence (§ 12-19-19(b)). Rule 32(f) applies the same hearing and preponderance requirements. If the court finds after a hearing that you met every term, you become immediately eligible for consideration for expungement (§ 12-19-19(c)). The terms include full payment of fines, fees, costs, assessments and restitution. Our post on Rhode Island deferred sentence terms and completion explains what completion requires.
Filings. A complaint placed on file under § 12-10-12 carries express conditions: keep the peace, be of good behavior and pay all court-imposed money (§ 12-10-12(b)). On a violation the court may impose a sanction or resurrect the filed matter. It decides whether a violation occurred using the probation procedures in §§ 12-19-9 and 12-19-14. If the complaint was filed after a guilty or nolo plea and the court finds a violation without imposing a sanction, it may sentence you (§ 12-10-12(c)). Domestic violence filings run for three years (§ 12-29-4(d)). Our post on Rhode Island criminal filing conditions and records covers the terms.
Preparing for a Rhode Island probation violation hearing
A violation allegation concerns an existing sentence and its conditions. Prepare the original sentencing documents and the alleged violation together. Do not stop following existing conditions because a hearing is pending. Contact counsel promptly even if you do not yet have every document.
- Original judgment, sentencing order, and written probation conditions.
- Violation notice, probation report, and any new complaint or summons.
- Court dates and custody information for each case.
- Relevant compliance records, receipts, messages, and program or treatment records.
Then build the record that the hearing will turn on.
- Bring the judgment, suspended-sentence terms, written probation conditions, and violation notice.
- Prepare a dated account of reporting, appointments, treatment, testing, payments, and communications with probation.
- Collect records supporting compliance or explaining a disputed missed requirement.
- Identify any new arrest, release conditions, custody status, or upcoming hearing.
Ask counsel which condition is alleged to have been violated, what evidence the state will offer, when the hearing is scheduled and what sentence is at issue. The written statement of grounds required by Rule 32(f) answers the first question. The original judgment answers the last. In Providence County, a District Court sentence is reviewed at the Garrahy Judicial Complex and a Superior Court sentence at the Licht Judicial Complex.
What a Rhode Island probation violation defense examines
- The condition. Which written condition is alleged to have been violated, and was it actually part of the judgment or the deferral agreement?
- The dates. Had the probation period expired under § 12-19-8(b) before the alleged conduct? Was the hearing held within 30 days of arrest, or was the limit waived?
- The proof. What evidence does the state have of the new conduct, and does it meet a fair preponderance? Police reports and the complainant's account are tested at the hearing.
- The technical violation. Does the division's written report describe a clear and articulable public safety risk, and did the division recommend time served under § 12-19-14(a)?
- Mitigation. Treatment, employment, family responsibilities, the length of compliance before the violation and the circumstances of the breach.
- The exposure. The suspended time, the lesser-sentence and stay options, credit for time held under § 12-19-2(a), and the sentencing benchmarks.
- The new case. How the hearing affects the pending charge, and whether § 12-19-18 will apply if the new charge is dismissed on a listed ground.
We review the original judgment, the specific conditions, the violation papers and the evidence of the alleged conduct. We discuss the hearing and the available options without promising a particular result. If the sentence was imposed in Massachusetts, see our Massachusetts criminal defense page, because Massachusetts probation procedure is different.
Frequently Asked Questions
A 32(f) hearing is a probation violation hearing, named for Rule 32(f) of the Rhode Island Superior Court Rules of Criminal Procedure. The rule bars the court from revoking probation or a suspended sentence, or imposing a deferred sentence, without a hearing. You may be present and must be told the grounds, and the state must prove the violation by a fair preponderance of the evidence.
A fair preponderance of the evidence. R.I. Gen. Laws §§ 12-19-9(b) and 12-19-14(b) and Rule 32(f) all use that standard, which is lower than proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The court decides whether you violated the terms of probation, not whether you are guilty of any new charge.
Yes, for a limited time. Under § 12-19-9(a) the court may hold you without bail for up to 10 days, excluding Saturdays, Sundays and holidays. Under § 12-19-14(a) that hold applies when the new charge is a violent crime, a domestic violence crime or a DUI. It also applies when the court finds public safety or flight concerns warrant it.
The court must conduct the hearing within 30 days of arrest unless you waive that limit, under R.I. Gen. Laws §§ 12-19-9(b) and 12-19-14(b). A waiver is sometimes used to let the new case develop first, and it is a decision to make with counsel.
If you were imprisoned for a violation based on a new charge, § 12-19-18(b) requires the court, on motion, to quash that sentence when the new charge ends in a listed way. The list covers a not guilty verdict, a Rule 29 acquittal or dismissal, a no true bill, a no information or Rule 9.1 dismissal for lack of probable cause, and a failure to proceed where the state doubts culpability. Other dismissals do not trigger the statute.
The court is not required to order the full suspended sentence served. Under §§ 12-19-9(b) and 12-19-14(b) it may continue the suspension, order a lesser sentence, stay part of the sentence or convert straight probation to a suspended sentence. It sentences under the judicial sentencing benchmarks. The division of rehabilitative services may also recommend that time already served is enough for a violation that is not a new crime.
Next step
Facing a probation violation in Rhode Island?
Tell us the court, the case number, the alleged violation, your custody status and the next date. The first consultation is free, and we check for conflicts before reviewing the matter with you.

