Rhode Island criminal defense

Rhode Island Domestic Violence Defense Lawyer

In Rhode Island, domestic violence is a label that R.I. Gen. Laws § 12-29-2 attaches to crimes such as simple assault when the people involved are family or household members. The label brings a no-contact order at release and added penalties under § 12-29-5 on a conviction, probation or a nolo filing. DiLibero & Associates defends domestic violence charges in the Rhode Island District Court and Superior Court from its Providence office.

Updated . General information, not legal advice. The first consultation is free.

What makes a Rhode Island charge domestic violence

Rhode Island has no single crime called domestic violence. Under R.I. Gen. Laws § 12-29-2(a), domestic violence means a listed crime committed by one family or household member against another. The list includes, but is not limited to:

  • Simple assault (§ 11-5-3), felony assault (chapter 5 of title 11) and domestic assault by strangulation (§ 11-5-2.3)
  • Vandalism (§ 11-44-1), disorderly conduct (§ 11-45-1) and trespass (§ 11-44-26)
  • Violation of a protective order, where the respondent knew of the order and the penalty for violating it, or of a no-contact order issued under § 12-29-4
  • Stalking (chapter 59 of title 11), cyberstalking and cyberharassment (§ 11-52-4.2), and refusing to relinquish or damaging a telephone (§ 11-35-14)
  • Kidnapping, child-snatching, sexual assault, homicide, burglary and unlawful entry, and arson
  • Electronic tracking of motor vehicles (§ 11-69-1)

The relationship is the second element. Under § 12-29-2(b), a family or household member means a spouse or former spouse, or an adult related by blood or marriage. It includes adults who live together now or lived together in the past three years. It includes people with a child in common, married or not. It also includes people in a substantive dating or engagement relationship within the past year.

The dating relationship is the part most often disputed. The court weighs three factors: the length of the relationship, its type, and how often the parties interacted. A brief or casual relationship may not qualify. That question can decide whether the label applies at all.

The label changes the case from the start. The complaint form must state whether the charge involves domestic violence and the relationship of the parties (§ 12-29-4(c)). The docket is marked (§ 12-29-4(b)(3)). The underlying penalty stays the same. Domestic simple assault still carries up to one year, a fine of up to $1,000, or both under § 11-5-3(a). But § 11-5-3(b) adds the § 12-29-5 penalties. Our guide to Rhode Island assault and battery charges covers the underlying offense.

The no-contact order issued at release

The first consequence arrives before arraignment. Under § 12-29-4(a)(1), a person charged with or arrested for a domestic violence crime may not be released before arraignment without first appearing before the court or a bail commissioner. The official who authorizes release must issue a no-contact order prohibiting contact with the victim. At arraignment or the bail hearing, the court decides whether to issue or extend the order (§ 12-29-4(a)(2)). It can also be made part of the disposition (§ 12-29-4(a)(3)).

The written order carries this legend: 'Violation of this order is a criminal offense under this section and will subject a violator to arrest'. A copy goes to the victim. The clerk sends each order, change or termination to the police by the next judicial day (§ 12-29-4(a)(5)). A willful violation is a misdemeanor (§ 12-29-4(a)(3)). It is also a domestic violence crime in its own right under § 12-29-2(a)(10), with the § 12-29-5 penalties below.

The other person cannot cancel the order. An invitation, a text or a request to talk about the children does not change it. Only the court can modify or end it, on a motion in the criminal case. Our page on Rhode Island no-contact order violations explains the charge. Our post on reading the conditions of a Rhode Island no-contact order covers housing, belongings and children.

Added penalties on conviction, probation or a nolo filing

R.I. Gen. Laws § 12-29-5 applies to every person convicted of, or placed on probation for, a domestic violence crime. It also applies when the case is placed on file under § 12-10-12 after a nolo contendere plea. These consequences are added to the sentence for the underlying crime.

  • Batterer's intervention program. The judge must order a certified batterer's intervention program at your own expense. It becomes a condition of probation, and noncompliance is a basis for a violation. The court cannot suspend or waive it. A servicemember or veteran may be allowed a court-approved program through the Veterans' Administration instead (§ 12-29-5(a)).
  • $125 assessment. Ordered on a conviction, on probation, and on a filing after a guilty or nolo plea (§ 12-29-5(b)).
  • Second domestic violence misdemeanor. Not less than 10 days and not more than one year in jail (§ 12-29-5(c)(1)(i)).
  • Third or later misdemeanor. A felony, punishable by one to 10 years (§ 12-29-5(c)(1)(ii)).
  • No suspension. No jail term under § 12-29-5 can be suspended (§ 12-29-5(c)(2)).
  • Firearm determination. On every nolo plea or conviction, the court decides whether you are now prohibited from possessing a firearm under § 11-47-5(a)(3) or (a)(4) (§ 12-29-5(d)).

A nolo contendere plea is not a soft landing. The court must tell you that a nolo plea has the same legal effect and collateral consequences as a guilty plea (§ 12-29-5(d)(1)). For a felony domestic violence offense, or a misdemeanor listed in § 11-47-5(a)(4), the court must also warn that the plea bars you from possessing any firearm (§ 12-29-5(d)(2)). The court orders your firearms surrendered (§ 12-29-5(g), (h)). Any firearm used in the offense is forfeited (§ 12-29-5(j)).

Domestic violence misdemeanor penalties under R.I. Gen. Laws § 12-29-5
ConvictionJail termAdded consequences
First domestic violence misdemeanorThe underlying penalty, for example up to 1 year for simple assault under § 11-5-3Batterer's intervention program at your expense, $125 assessment, firearm determination
Second domestic violence misdemeanor10 days to 1 year, no suspensionSame added consequences
Third or later domestic violence misdemeanorFelony, 1 to 10 years, no suspensionSame added consequences, plus the felony firearm prohibition under § 11-47-5(a)(3)

Domestic assault by strangulation is a separate felony

Rhode Island treats strangulation of a family or household member as its own felony. Under § 11-5-2.3(a), an assault or battery by strangulation on a family or household member is punishable by up to 10 years. The § 12-29-5 penalties also apply (§ 11-5-2.3(b)). Strangulation means knowingly and intentionally impeding normal breathing or circulation of the blood, with intent to cause harm (§ 11-5-2.3(c)). It can be done by pressure on the throat or neck, or by blocking the nose or mouth. Knowledge and intent are both elements the prosecution must prove.

Other domestic assaults can be felonies too. Under § 11-5-2(a), an assault with a dangerous weapon, or one that causes serious bodily injury, is a felony assault. It carries up to 20 years if serious bodily injury results and up to six years otherwise. Serious bodily injury is defined in § 11-5-2(c). Felony charges are heard in the Superior Court.

Filings and your record in a domestic violence case

Many Rhode Island misdemeanors end with the complaint placed on file under § 12-10-12. The court may file a non-felony complaint for a period up to the maximum jail sentence, with conditions. Every filing requires you to keep the peace, be of good behavior and pay all court-imposed money (§ 12-10-12(b)).

Domestic violence filings follow stricter rules. Under § 12-29-4(d), the filing is conditioned on keeping the peace and good behavior for three years. Under § 12-1-12(c), the records cannot be expunged, sealed or destroyed for three years from the filing date, whatever the plea was.

The three-year clock has a reward at the end. Under § 12-10-12(d), if you are not charged with a violation during the filing period, the complaint is automatically quashed. If no new domestic violence charge follows within three years, or one is brought and then dismissed or acquitted, the records are expunged without a motion. If a violation is found after a guilty or nolo plea, the court may sentence you on the original charge. The earlier plea can also be considered if you are sentenced for a new domestic violence crime within those three years.

A domestic violence conviction is harder to clear. Convictions under chapter 29 of title 12 are excluded from the route that expunges several misdemeanors at once (§ 12-1.3-2(b)). A first offender with a single conviction may still move to expunge a misdemeanor five years after completing the sentence, or a felony after 10 years. The crime must not be a crime of violence under § 12-1.3-1. See our pages on Rhode Island expungement and Rhode Island criminal filing conditions and records.

The civil protective order is a separate track

A no-contact order comes from the criminal case. A protective order, often called a restraining order, is a civil order the other person asks for. Under § 12-29-2(c), it means an order under § 15-5-19, chapter 15 of title 15, or chapter 8.1 of title 8. The two orders can exist at the same time with different terms. One does not change the other.

Under § 15-15-3(a), a person suffering from domestic abuse may file a complaint in the Family Court. The court may bar contact, order the defendant to vacate the household, award custody of minor children and, after a hearing, order child support for up to 90 days. Under § 8-8.1-3(a), a similar complaint may be filed in the District Court, which cannot order a defendant who holds the sole legal interest in the home to vacate it. Both courts order firearms surrendered within 24 hours of notice.

Relief runs for a fixed period of up to three years, extendable on the plaintiff's motion. Either party may move to modify it at any time (§ 15-15-3(m)(2); § 8-8.1-3(n)). Violating an order you had actual notice of is a misdemeanor. It carries a fine of up to $1,000, up to one year in jail, or both, plus the § 12-29-5 penalties (§ 15-15-3(n); § 8-8.1-3(o), (q)). A violation can also be punished as contempt. The District Court hears adult violations.

The firearm consequence is immediate. Under § 11-47-5(b), a person subject to such an order, issued after notice and an opportunity to be heard, may not possess a firearm. A person who surrendered firearms gets a hearing within 15 days. There, the restrained person must show by clear and convincing evidence that restoring firearm rights would not pose a danger (§ 15-15-3(b), (j); § 8-8.1-3(b), (j)). Tell your lawyer if you are served with a protective order complaint while a criminal case is pending. What you say at the civil hearing can be used in the criminal case.

What happens next in a Rhode Island domestic violence case

  1. Arrest and release. You appear before a judge or bail commissioner before release. That official sets bail and issues the no-contact order (§ 12-29-4(a)(1)). The responding officer completes a domestic violence report whether or not an arrest occurs (§ 12-29-8(a)).
  2. Arraignment. Misdemeanor charges such as simple assault, disorderly conduct, vandalism and trespass are arraigned in the District Court. Providence County cases are heard at the Garrahy Judicial Complex at 1 Dorrance Plaza. Kent County cases go to the Noel Judicial Complex in Warwick, Washington County to the McGrath Judicial Complex in Wakefield, and Newport County to the Murray Judicial Complex. The court decides whether the no-contact order continues.
  3. Felony charges. Felony assault, strangulation and a third domestic violence misdemeanor are heard in the Superior Court. In Providence that is the Licht Judicial Complex at 250 Benefit Street.
  4. Pretrial. After a not guilty plea, the court schedules a pretrial conference. The defense reviews the statements, photographs, recordings and the domestic violence report. Motions can challenge a search, a statement or the relationship element.
  5. Trial or disposition. At trial the prosecution must prove each element of the underlying crime and the relationship. A case can also end by dismissal, a filing, a plea or a verdict, each with the consequences above.

Two rules shape the process. The court may not dismiss a charge or delay disposition because a divorce or other civil case is pending (§ 12-29-4(b)(1)). It may not require proof that either party seeks a divorce (§ 12-29-4(b)(2)). The court must make clear to the defendant and the victim that the prosecutor, not the victim, decides whether the case goes forward (§ 12-29-4(b)(4)). Read what happens at an arraignment in Providence before your first date.

What a Rhode Island domestic violence defense examines

Domestic violence cases are built on accounts, and accounts can be tested. These are the questions we ask in nearly every case.

  • The relationship. Is the complainant a family or household member under § 12-29-2(b)? For a dating relationship, do the length, type and frequency of contact make it substantive?
  • The underlying crime. What does the evidence show about each element of the assault, disorderly conduct or vandalism charged? An argument is not an assault.
  • The statements. The 911 call, the on-scene accounts, written statements and later interviews, and whether they match each other, the photographs and the timeline.
  • The physical evidence. Photographs, medical records and the timing of each record. For a strangulation charge, the proof of knowledge and intent under § 11-5-2.3(c).
  • Self-defense and the police response. Injuries to both parties, who called the police, and the domestic violence report required by § 12-29-8. That report records the relationship, the alleged abuse, weapons, children present and any prior order.
  • The disposition. Whether a filing, a plea, probation or trial fits the case. The three-year filing rule, the program, the assessment, the firearm determination and any immigration or licensing consequences are weighed first.

We assess the allegations, the release conditions and the available defenses without promising a particular result.

Documents to prepare for the consultation

Preserve originals. Discuss witness contact with counsel before reaching out to anyone, and keep complying with every court order. Bring what you have, even if the file is incomplete.

  • Complaint or summons, case number, and next hearing date.
  • Bail papers, no-contact orders, and any civil or family court orders.
  • Original messages, photographs, recordings, and possible witness names.
  • Information about housing or property arrangements that require attention.

Keep each court's papers identifiable. Where more than one proceeding is involved, list the court, case number, next date and document title for each. List practical questions about housing, medication, belongings, work and children so counsel can review them against the actual documents. Explain any gaps rather than recreating a missing conversation.

If you are on probation or have a filing or deferred sentence, gather the Rhode Island probation violation documents too, because a new charge can trigger a violation hearing. If the charge is in Massachusetts, start with our Massachusetts criminal defense page.

Frequently Asked Questions

It depends on the underlying crime. Domestic simple assault, disorderly conduct and trespass are misdemeanors. Felony assault under R.I. Gen. Laws § 11-5-2, strangulation under § 11-5-2.3 and a third domestic violence misdemeanor, which carries one to 10 years under § 12-29-5(c), are felonies.

No. Under R.I. Gen. Laws § 12-29-4(b)(4), the prosecutor, not the victim, decides whether the case is prosecuted. The court may not dismiss or delay the case because a divorce or other civil case is pending (§ 12-29-4(b)(1)). The no-contact order stays in force until the court itself changes it.

Up to one year in jail, a fine of up to $1,000, or both under R.I. Gen. Laws § 11-5-3. A conviction, probation or nolo filing also brings a batterer's intervention program at your expense, a $125 assessment and a firearm determination under § 12-29-5.

Under R.I. Gen. Laws § 11-47-5(a), a conviction or nolo plea for felony domestic violence bars firearm possession. So does one for domestic simple assault, cyberstalking, a protective order violation, or disorderly conduct involving force or a weapon threat. The bar lasts until the matter is expunged or a one-year filing or one-year probation ends without a conviction. A civil protective order issued after notice and a hearing also bars possession while it is in effect.

A domestic violence filing cannot be expunged or sealed for three years under R.I. Gen. Laws § 12-1-12(c), but if no new domestic violence charge follows in that time the records are expunged automatically under § 12-10-12(d). A conviction is excluded from the multiple-misdemeanor route under § 12-1.3-2(b). A first offender may move to expunge a misdemeanor after five years or a felony after 10, if it is not a listed crime of violence.

A no-contact order is a criminal order issued by the court or bail commissioner under R.I. Gen. Laws § 12-29-4, and the other person does not apply for it. A restraining order, called a protective order in the statutes, is a civil order the other person requests in the Family Court (§ 15-15-3) or the District Court (§ 8-8.1-3). Both can be in force at once, and violating either is a crime.

Next step

Charged with domestic violence in Rhode Island?

Call 401-621-9700 or send us a message with the court, the charge and the no-contact order you received. The first consultation is free, and we check for conflicts before discussing the facts.

130 Dorrance Street, Providence, RI 02903 · Monday to Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.